Being gifted needs courage.
~Georg Brandes
This is a two part post. This section deals with the basics of gifted kids and gifted education. It is meant as a primer to give parents tools and information to open a dialogue with school administrators, teachers, other parents, and/or medical professionals. Part two will deal exclusively with emotional concerns for parents and kids. I have consulted gifted children themselves, parents of gifted children, and adults who are gifted to try and bring a unique perspective from inside the gifted world.
Exactly who
is gifted?*
The Federal definition of gifted
students is as follows: “The term 'gifted and talented' when used in respect to
students, children, or youth means [those who show] evidence of high
performance capability in areas such as intellectual, creative, artistic, or leadership
capacity, or in specific academic fields, and who require services or
activities not ordinarily provided by the school in order to fully develop such
capabilities.”
— P.L. 103–382, Title XIV, p. 388
Unlike special education which is
protected by the Federal mandate called The Individuals with Disability Education Act
(IDEA), gifted students, while being considered special needs learners, are not
covered by IDEA. There are Federal
recommendations on what services a gifted child should receive, but since is no mandate, the services for gifted children are determined by each state
individually and are funded (or not funded) by the state as well. This represents one of the greatest
disservices to gifted children who are, without services, ignored, left to fend
for themselves, and dismissed as being smart enough to handle everything on
their own. One woman in my gifted
parenting support group said, when she requested an interview about her son’s
giftedness, the superintendent of her school district said there was no such
thing as a Gifted Individual Education Plan (GIEP) and one will not be provided for a child who performs above the
curve. The man who is supposed to be an advocate for every skill level of every
child was unimpressed with the idea of a GIEP and dismissed it as a drain on my school district’s
resources. Some advocate.
My
10 year old daughter is smart. I tell
people she is scary smart, not just average smart. Dealing with a gifted child
is difficult because, unbeknownst to many people there are many problem areas
for gifted children, the most common being emotional, educational, social, and
intellectual difficulties. When gifted
children are ignored one, many, or all of these problems can manifest and your
child may act out, become emotionally unstable, be bored, or give up on
education. There are ways to combat
these problems, by yourself if you have to. Remember, YOU are your child’s only
true advocate. No one but you would give
up everything for her to have a happy life.
My daughter was
identified as gifted in first grade. In
kindergarten one spring afternoon I was asked to stay behind after class when
picking up my daughter. This was not an
unusual request. Madeline had been a
student at a Piaget modeled daycare/kindergarten school for about three years
and she constantly shocked the teachers with her advanced cognitive functions, perceptional reasoning and advanced reading level. She was 5. I was told to have my daughter tested for gifted. I remember I wasn't tested until I was in third grade. She was in kindergarten. Her kindergarten teacher said, "No. Test her as soon as she starts first grade." She was serious.
In the Commonwealth of PA, as
parents we have the right to ask the school to assess our children for learning
support or giftedness. The school
district must accommodate us in a reasonable amount of time at no cost to us. That is one of the first things you need to
investigate in regard to your district. In
regard to testing, what rights do you
have? The best place to start is with your class teacher. If he/she does not know, move on to the principal. If the principal is unsure contact your administration building.
A test is a test is a test?
As a gifted individual
myself, the gifted aptitude tests are now very different from when I took them
35 years ago. When I was a child I
remember being given shadow shapes and blocks and being asked to reproduce the
shape by putting the blocks together. I
remember being asked to do mazes.
Apparently I did them backwards which is the sign, at least 35 years
ago, of advanced cognitive function. I was told by my mother that I was given an
IQ test and I tested, obviously, quite high.
And that was it (well, that's what I remember. It's fair to say there might have been more to it). Big rubber stamp
on my forehead: GIFTED. I was given a
GIEP and placed in a classroom with
other higher learners. I was taken out
of the classroom and put in a gifted resource room once every couple of days to do special
projects (which I now know was cognitive enhancement). That was it. No additional services. No psychological services. No counseling. Nothing. Nada. And I sure needed more looking back now.
When my daughter was
tested the process was quite different.
She was given what is called a multidiscipline test. In other words, she was observed by many
people, including her father and me. She was
observed in a classroom setting by our district’s gifted itinerant (a
specialized teacher who deals exclusively with gifted children). Her classroom teachers filled out
questionnaires. We filled out
questionnaires. She was given a IQ
test. The test she took is the Wechsler
Intelligence Scale for Children (WISC).
This test measures her cognitive ability (brained based skills required to
understand and carry out tasks) and her Perceptual Reasoning Index (which
measures fluid reasoning, ability to learn new information, and spacial
processing). Her previous teachers were interviewed. The results of this test indicated that she
was highly gifted and talented (often referred to as GT) and needed to be in a program that would help her
educationally, emotionally, and intellectually. During my years as a gifted student the emotional aspect of being gifted was overlooked. Only now do we see that emotional support is
very necessary for smart kids. Gifted children don't think the same way normal children do. Their brains work in different, more efficient ways in many cases, but the way in which information is given to gifted children, or the processes which they are taught to use sometimes don't make sense. They process information quickly and their brains are hypersensitive to stimuli. Regular teaching models are inadequate for their minds and they can become frustrated and hard on themselves causes emotional pain. We must see to all aspects of their brains. The holistic model of care is the most appropriate.
Here is a fascinating article from Johns Hopkins University on how a gifted brain works: Johns Hopkins University: Brains on Fire
Here is a fascinating article from Johns Hopkins University on how a gifted brain works: Johns Hopkins University: Brains on Fire
Gifted testing tests three specific areas: verbal reasoning (understanding and reasoning with concept framed in words), quantitative reasoning (the application of mathematical concepts and skills to solve real-world problems), and non-verbal
reasoning (the use of mental strategies to solve problems). Because there are several different ways of thinking children don't necessarily test gifted in all areas which means children can be gifted in one area, regular track in another,
and even special needs in yet another. I
taught in a 6th grade special education resource room for five
years. On several occasions I had children with a GIEP in math and an IEP in
reading. Their time was split between
gifted cluster math, a reading resource room, and regular tracked history and
science. The mind is a strange and
wonderful thing.
What is this GIEP thing?
A GIEP is a individual learning plan for your child. All IEPs, whether for special education or gifted students, are written for each individual child. While the form is generic, the information entered is intended only for your child. There are several sections to an IEP. First, the IEP includes the letters and communication between parents and teachers to set up appointments and the parent's acknowledgments of their rights as parents. It includes a section indicating parties invited to participate in an IEP meeting by listing each and asking for a signature if they are in attendance. This list often includes the parents, the current teachers, the principal, the gifted itinerant or school psychologist, and the student.
The second section of an IEP includes information on the child. This includes test results, academic and cognitive strengths, concerns (both parents and teachers if applicable), progress on goals as of the meeting date, aptitudes, interests, specialized skills, and products and evidence of effectiveness in other academic areas. It also may include special services already in place or recommended for the child (such as speech therapy) or any health diagnoses (anything from "student must wear corrective lenses" to "student exhibits Asperger's Syndrome").
The third portion of the IEP outlines the actual education plan. An example on my daughter's GIEP is as follows:
Annual Goal: Given advanced language arts curriculum, Madeline will develop high-level reading and writing skills.
Short Term Learning Outcomes for this Goal: 1. Given an inquiry focus question, Madeline will write a response and then revise that response after analysis of the groups' discussion.
Objective criteria: Relevant written responses before and after every discussion (100% of sessions).
Assessment procedures: Teacher checklist and rubric.
Timeline: Monthly units of Instruction, quarterly progress reports. Etc...
Objective criteria: Relevant written responses before and after every discussion (100% of sessions).
Assessment procedures: Teacher checklist and rubric.
Timeline: Monthly units of Instruction, quarterly progress reports. Etc...
The GIEP gives a plan for Madeline's education and makes sure she doesn't get lost in the shuffle.
So Where do we Put Them?
There are genearlly three options
for gifted education in a brick and mortal school. While some are better than others, many gifted parents
will take what they get, happy that their child is at least being served in
some capacity.
The first is the
self-contained classroom. This is often the most desired situation for most parents of a
gifted student but not always an option (or even the best option in some cases).
A self-contained classroom (or also called homogeneous grouping) is precisely what it
sounds like, a classroom that only houses gifted and advanced students. Sometimes if there are only a
few students from each grade, a self-contained classroom will have students from multiple
grades. This can be very beneficial because younger students have older students to look to. On the opposite side of the intellectual
spectrum are self-contained classrooms used for special needs learners that
do not qualify for certain areas on regular track inclusion. Self-contained classrooms, whether advanced or special needs often deviate from the
standard curriculum and allow the students to advance as they will with support
from a trained teacher, a gifted or special education itinerant if available, and sometimes a classroom paraprofessional. The gifted classroom is not just accelerated. The students' coursework is advanced and supported by their learning materials and their
teachers. Many people think that simple
acceleration is the key to teaching a gifted student. This is not the case. Acceleration without teaching
cognitive skills can be the recipe for disaster. That’s like giving a child a car but
neglecting to teach them how to drive.
Gifted children need not only to be given information, but to be taught how to think. Their reasoning is different from the average
child.
One of the benefits of a
self-contained classroom is that all of the gifted and advanced students are
together and they have progressed together.
Within their classroom you will find comradery and peer support. They are all super smart. And they know it. There is little teasing or bullying, or
negative response from other students when one of them wants to talk about how the Theory of Relativity applies when mommy makes dinner. They don’t laugh at each other and when they
call each other nerds or geeks they own the word. It is not a derogatory term. There is no real
jealousy and they all respect each other. Is this the norm? Definitely not in the real world which is one of the cons to this sort of arrangement.
One significant problem
with the self-contained classroom is the future of a student’s academics if
he/she moves to another school that does not have self-contained classrooms. While moving throughout a supportive district
that will test gifted children to put them exactly where they belong
academically, some schools don’t accommodate advancement. Maddie plays the violin and her father and I
were seriously considering a performing arts middle charter school because the public
school district has seriously and obscenely cut the arts programs. I called the arts charter school and after
about four attempts, spoke to the school counselor. I asked if they accommodated GIEPs. They said they did not. They were only
required to accommodate special needs IEPs as covered by IDEA. I asked if Maddie would be tested and placed
in a proper academic level, whether it put her in a higher grade or not. The answer was still no. They do not accommodate advanced
learner. Would I like an application
anyway? I think not. This is a typical problem when changing to a
school that does not assist gifted students.
Your child could leave one school learning at a fifth grade level only
to be returned to a third grade curriculum. Do research before you change
schools.
The second, and most
common type of support is called cluster grouping. Gifted and advanced students
are placed in a heterogeneous classroom, but as you would expect, clustered
together and given additional instruction whether they are pulled out for
enrichment periods (such as the Junior Great Books programs), or having a
higher level math courses taught while other math classes are going on. These clusters work at an accelerated pace,
learn more complex ideas, higher order thinking skills, and an enriching curriculum.
Clustering works well as long as there is a qualified teacher for the classroom
and few or no disruptive students assigned in the non-clustered section of
class. In regard to socialization,
cluster grouping in a heterogeneous classroom has the benefit of keeping intellectual
peers together for support, but gives them access to others in their age group. Self-contained classrooms can make students seem elitist and cause social divide in peers of the same
age leading to the possibilities of more active teasing and bullying and
general social isolation of the advanced students.
The pull-out or send-out
method, or sometimes referred to as the resource room method, is the least desirable
of the three accommodations. Many districts follow this model (sometimes because of lack of funding for highly qualified teachers and sometimes because of low gifted enrollment) and
this method is better than no method at all. Students are taken out of regular
academic classrooms for one or two hours a week where they have special
training, receive gifted support, or have special enrichment. Unfortunately two
to six hours a week is not enough time to truly provide for the gifted student’s
academic or emotional needs, but at least it attempts to give the student
skills to use. For a better look at the
pros and cons of all three of these methods, please visit the Duke University
Talent Identification Program website at: Duke TIP
Problems!
One of the biggest
emotional issues with gifted children is pressure whether real or perceived. It can be a burden to be smart. You are expected to get things right. You are
expected to lead. You are expected to be
profound. You cannot fail. But then
again, if you show your intelligence you are a show off and arrogant. You can’t win.
As a parent the most
important thing you must do is be very, very aware of your child’s moods and
responses to the world around her. As
smart as gifted kids are, they are like every other kid out there…sometimes
they don’t know how to say they are upset.
Be aware of certain warning signs:
When you know the
material is at the right level, but your child seems to be doing poorly make an appointment
with his teacher. A lot of schooling
comes very easily to gifted kids and they do very well, but there is a little
part of them that wonders what will happen if they fail, and sometimes they
fail on purpose to find out if the world is going to end. I know a young man that in the final years of
high school, after an illustrious school career, purposefully failed every
class. The world didn’t end. His mom was pissed. He moved on with his life. He knows now that what he did hurt his
chances to get into a better college.
Don’t let your child get to that point.
Let them fail in a controlled manner and without pressure. Identify the problem (your child got a “B” on
a math test…and believe me this could be a situation that leads to
meltdown). Make the grade OK (That’s a
good grade, honey. I know it’s not what you like, but it’s still really good). Ask and suggest. Don’t accuse. (It looks like
you had a little trouble on this problem? Maybe we can figure it out
together.) Make it OK for both of you to
fail and look for help (Well honey, I stink at this problem too. Why don’t we ask the teacher tomorrow). And let it go. Don’t focus on it for the rest
of the night and when your child returns to the subject, move it along. Let's talk about something else. Let's talk about something that makes you feel good inside.
If you are concerned that your child is having trouble at school and you there isn't an obvious reason, ask to have the itinerant or psychologist observe your child. You have the right to ask for this. My daughter had 5 minute interval observations once because she seemed to be having difficulties in the area of math. Every five minutes the itinerant wrote down what she was doing…and I mean everything including “finger in her nose.” We met after the observation and she was able to detect one of two main areas that was causing problems. Maddie would often start tests and works without waiting for instructions. While she easily blew through most of the test, she was unable to do the problems that the teacher took time to explain. She would be on the last question (the one that had instructions) and just after the teacher finished explaining Madeline would raise her hand and say she didn't know how to do the question that was just explained. A one hour observation saved us from significant problems down the road.
If you are concerned that your child is having trouble at school and you there isn't an obvious reason, ask to have the itinerant or psychologist observe your child. You have the right to ask for this. My daughter had 5 minute interval observations once because she seemed to be having difficulties in the area of math. Every five minutes the itinerant wrote down what she was doing…and I mean everything including “finger in her nose.” We met after the observation and she was able to detect one of two main areas that was causing problems. Maddie would often start tests and works without waiting for instructions. While she easily blew through most of the test, she was unable to do the problems that the teacher took time to explain. She would be on the last question (the one that had instructions) and just after the teacher finished explaining Madeline would raise her hand and say she didn't know how to do the question that was just explained. A one hour observation saved us from significant problems down the road.
This can be one of the original
triggers of poor school performance. Even children who live with no pressure at
home or at school can succumb to internal anxiety. Again, gifted kids know they are smart and
they know a lot is expected of them.
Even if you make that “B” OK, they might not feel it’s OK and they may
feel as though they let you or their teacher down (even though they haven’t). Recently my daughter stopped wanting to speak
up in class. She said she was afraid of saying the wrong thing and embarrassing
herself. I told her walking into a sign
post was embarrassing. The wrong answer isn’t.
But I’ll be honest: that’s only a gifted parent half-truth. Wrong
answers are embarrassing to a gifted individual and we obsess over them,
sometimes for years. In my Edgar Allan Poe class in college the professor asked
the rhyme scene/meter of “The Raven.” I
answered incorrectly even though I realized the correct answer just as the
wrong answer was coming out of my mouth.
I am still fixated on it (Trochaic Octameter in case you
were interested…I said septameter). The best you can do is reassure, reassure,
reassure, reassure. If the anxiety
increases please consult your itinerant or psychologist. He or she will give you additional symptoms of anxiety to watch for. Things such as sleepwalking, wetting the bed, crying for no apparent reason, etc...can all be signs that your child is struggling inside. Dealing with anxiety is one of the things
that I was never taught. Even at 35 one of my professors said I was “twitchy”
when it came to writing papers asking her every other day if this was
acceptable, or was that what she meant with that instruction. There is truth in
fiction. During a Simpsons episode the
school strikes and Lisa (a gifted child) begins to go a bit crazy when there is
no education. She begs her mother to
rate her and grade her because she can’t stand the fact that she isn’t learning
and being assessed, something that becomes very important to gifted children. Marge writes an “A” on a blank piece of paper and
Lisa glides away happily.
This is one of the most
common signs that something isn’t wrong.
Most often it means that a gifted child is bored with the curriculum. It
is either moving too quickly and they quit or it is moving too slow and they finish
their work before anyone else and are left to their own devises, often getting
in trouble. This is when a gifted itinerant or school psychologist is worth
their weight in gold. Once again, an
itinerant or psychologist observation may be in order to help identify when the
boredom occurs. Once identified it can be dealt with.
One of the ways I've tried to combat boredom in school (which, gifted cluster or not, still happens) is provide my own enrichment materials for Maddie. With permission from her teacher Maddie has a folder that I gave to her the first day of school. Over the summer we pick poems of all levels and make a booklet she can keep with her. We've included Keats, Silverstein, Poe, Tennyson, Eliot, and random poets of every age and walk of life found all over the internet. Some of these poems are difficult, even for adults. But they keep her thinking and they occupy her mind. Over the years she has even memorized quite a few stanzas from "The Lady of Shallot" by Alfred, Lord Tennyson.
Other ideas are sending your child with a writing journal with pre-written prompts. You and your child can create these prompts over the summer. Consider printing copies of great works of art. Include facts about the artist and the piece itself and leave a section for your child to write his thoughts. Pack extra books of high interest. Word searches. Crossword puzzles. Rubix cubes. Whatever you and your child's teacher deem appropriate. Having access to materials such as this can actually be entered into an GIEP if all parties agree. Your child can quietly get their materials and it will hopefully cut down the pencil tapping, foot kicking, draping over chairs, throwing things at other students, etc...
One of the ways I've tried to combat boredom in school (which, gifted cluster or not, still happens) is provide my own enrichment materials for Maddie. With permission from her teacher Maddie has a folder that I gave to her the first day of school. Over the summer we pick poems of all levels and make a booklet she can keep with her. We've included Keats, Silverstein, Poe, Tennyson, Eliot, and random poets of every age and walk of life found all over the internet. Some of these poems are difficult, even for adults. But they keep her thinking and they occupy her mind. Over the years she has even memorized quite a few stanzas from "The Lady of Shallot" by Alfred, Lord Tennyson.
Other ideas are sending your child with a writing journal with pre-written prompts. You and your child can create these prompts over the summer. Consider printing copies of great works of art. Include facts about the artist and the piece itself and leave a section for your child to write his thoughts. Pack extra books of high interest. Word searches. Crossword puzzles. Rubix cubes. Whatever you and your child's teacher deem appropriate. Having access to materials such as this can actually be entered into an GIEP if all parties agree. Your child can quietly get their materials and it will hopefully cut down the pencil tapping, foot kicking, draping over chairs, throwing things at other students, etc...
Maddie during a short school program. Her kingdom for a book. |
Troubling behavior in and out of school
Behavioral problems which might include
violence, severe disrespect, or acting out verbally are troubling for all involved. This is a step above tapping pencils and throwing spit balls. In cases such of this you need to do several things. First, evaluate
your child’s schedule (which could have too many activities). Kids get tired. Quickly. And when they are tired they can get angry and act out to show how unhappy they are. The older they get the worse it can become. Constant enrichment might seem like a great idea, but know when is too much. Don't take them to symphonies that will conclude after 11PM. That's just smart parenting. Your child needs down time. He MUST have it. He has to eat bugs, rub poison ivy on himself to see what happens, and skin his knees. Don't forget that they are children, not little adults. Children first.
Evaluate your child's peer relationships to see if they are troubled or non-existent. Man is a social creature and being forcefully ostracized is not healthy. It's one thing to choose to be alone. It is quite another to be forced to be alone. If your child is having trouble making or maintaining friends and consult with the itinerant or school psychologist (There is more on this subject coming up). If there seems to be no known reason or your child is showing extreme or harmful behavior I recommend making an appointment with a board certified child psychologist. Contrary to popular belief a doctor’s first instinct is not to pump a kid full of drugs. Psychologists and psychiatrists (medical doctors) assess your child and try to work out action plans which might include therapy, coping skills, changes in diet or schedules, and the worst case scenario of medication. Don’t be afraid of the medical profession. It’s there to help.
There has always been the myth that highly gifted and talented people are tragic and doomed because mental illness is more prevalent due to their unnatural intelligence. It has even been suggested that people are gifted because they are mentally ill, as though creativity is some sort of illness overflow. There is really no way to prove this theory and if you'll forgive me I'll use a very technical word to describe this idea: hogwash. Out of 100 gifted people let's say 15 of them are mentally ill. Wow! That's a lot. Well, not really. Out of 100 average people let's say 15 of them are mentally ill. Same number. Not as fabulous. Society likes the cool story, not the average story. Bob the plumber is schizophrenic. Meh. Angela the painter is schizophrenic. Wow! You can see her pain in the painting! It's all about perception. Will some gifted and talented kids have mental illness? Sure they will. Just like others. In this way, gifted kids aren't different. People see gifted children as exotic and different so they adhere to their own perception of what is exotic and different, which usually means being mentally ill. To me, it seems likes sometimes people think there is no way a person can be a Sylvia Plath or an Ernest Hemingway without having some sort of special edge, something extra added to the old "normal human" mix. The skills of these people are almost otherworldly, therefore there must be an explanation. They have the crazy. That's got to be it. Normal people don't write like Virginia Woolf.
Recent studies do show a correlation between mental illness and giftedness, but one of the primary rules of understanding studies such as this is correlation does not necessarily mean causation. An article in Molecular Psychicatry states: "Anecdotal and biographical reports have long suggested that bipolar disorder is more common in people with exceptional cognitive or creative ability. Epidemiological evidence for such a link is sparse."
Is bipolar disorder more common in highly intelligent people? A cohort study of a million men.
Evaluate your child's peer relationships to see if they are troubled or non-existent. Man is a social creature and being forcefully ostracized is not healthy. It's one thing to choose to be alone. It is quite another to be forced to be alone. If your child is having trouble making or maintaining friends and consult with the itinerant or school psychologist (There is more on this subject coming up). If there seems to be no known reason or your child is showing extreme or harmful behavior I recommend making an appointment with a board certified child psychologist. Contrary to popular belief a doctor’s first instinct is not to pump a kid full of drugs. Psychologists and psychiatrists (medical doctors) assess your child and try to work out action plans which might include therapy, coping skills, changes in diet or schedules, and the worst case scenario of medication. Don’t be afraid of the medical profession. It’s there to help.
There has always been the myth that highly gifted and talented people are tragic and doomed because mental illness is more prevalent due to their unnatural intelligence. It has even been suggested that people are gifted because they are mentally ill, as though creativity is some sort of illness overflow. There is really no way to prove this theory and if you'll forgive me I'll use a very technical word to describe this idea: hogwash. Out of 100 gifted people let's say 15 of them are mentally ill. Wow! That's a lot. Well, not really. Out of 100 average people let's say 15 of them are mentally ill. Same number. Not as fabulous. Society likes the cool story, not the average story. Bob the plumber is schizophrenic. Meh. Angela the painter is schizophrenic. Wow! You can see her pain in the painting! It's all about perception. Will some gifted and talented kids have mental illness? Sure they will. Just like others. In this way, gifted kids aren't different. People see gifted children as exotic and different so they adhere to their own perception of what is exotic and different, which usually means being mentally ill. To me, it seems likes sometimes people think there is no way a person can be a Sylvia Plath or an Ernest Hemingway without having some sort of special edge, something extra added to the old "normal human" mix. The skills of these people are almost otherworldly, therefore there must be an explanation. They have the crazy. That's got to be it. Normal people don't write like Virginia Woolf.
Recent studies do show a correlation between mental illness and giftedness, but one of the primary rules of understanding studies such as this is correlation does not necessarily mean causation. An article in Molecular Psychicatry states: "Anecdotal and biographical reports have long suggested that bipolar disorder is more common in people with exceptional cognitive or creative ability. Epidemiological evidence for such a link is sparse."
Is bipolar disorder more common in highly intelligent people? A cohort study of a million men.
No one likes me
Friends are often a touchy subject with gifted kids. Some gifted kids have only a few friends and this can be exacerbated if there is
no clustering, self-contained classes, or gifted grouping at school. Peers in your child's age group may
become jealous of your child’s knowledge or be put off by what they consider to
be strange behavior (a child who likes to rattle off the Fibonacci number
sequence or do the Knight’s Tour by memory for fun). No one likes a show off, but the problem is, gifted kids aren't showing off. They are being themselves. Sometimes they have strange interests. Sometimes they have average interests but hyperfocus and talk about one subject often. Parents of gifted kids understand this. Gifted kids understand this about themselves. Other people? Other kids? No so much.
Gifted kids like to talk. A lot. To you. At you. To the wall if people won't listen. Maddie's kindergarten teacher said her belly was full of words. My neighbor's son is gifted. One evening I babysat him and his sister with Maddie with us. I made dinner and sat them down at the table. Maddie and ZV (not to be confused with Maddie's girlfriend ZP below) didn't stop talking. At each other. Talking about two totally different subjects. I was amazed. Later I told his mother what happened. She said, "So you have one of those too?" Ha! But constant talking is very hard to take if you aren't used to it. Most kids aren't used to it. They see gifted kids as bossy and selfish wanting only to talk about things they like. It's not that way I assure you. They are just passionate. But that kind of passion sometimes doesn't make friends, or keep them. Gifted kids need to find other gifted kids.
Other
children might distance themselves from the weirdo. Now it’s up to you parents. You need to find
the others. They're there. I promise.
Gifted kids like to talk. A lot. To you. At you. To the wall if people won't listen. Maddie's kindergarten teacher said her belly was full of words. My neighbor's son is gifted. One evening I babysat him and his sister with Maddie with us. I made dinner and sat them down at the table. Maddie and ZV (not to be confused with Maddie's girlfriend ZP below) didn't stop talking. At each other. Talking about two totally different subjects. I was amazed. Later I told his mother what happened. She said, "So you have one of those too?" Ha! But constant talking is very hard to take if you aren't used to it. Most kids aren't used to it. They see gifted kids as bossy and selfish wanting only to talk about things they like. It's not that way I assure you. They are just passionate. But that kind of passion sometimes doesn't make friends, or keep them. Gifted kids need to find other gifted kids.
Maddie and her best buddy. Both highly gifted. |
Maddie and ZP made up their own language to talk to each other secretly. |
Gifted children need to
figure out where they belong and find people that have the same passions they
do. There are many ways to do this. A
child is interested in physics but her science teacher can neither explain it
in any way that makes sense to her nor recommend any age appropriate
books. This is when you find a physics
teacher or professor in your area. I guarantee
you these men and women would jump at the chance to bring an eager young mind
into the fold and be able to not only recommend resources, but be able to
answer questions. You might even be able
to ask a high school science teacher to allow your child to sit in on a
class. No one expects your child to
understand everything that’s being said.
It’s the impression and the feeling that they belong somewhere, that there are others like
them.
My daughter loves
science fiction. She gets it. Not all of
it, but since she loves science as well she can see how imagination advances
science knowledge. A few weeks ago my
city sponsored a Comic Book Conventions (often called ComicCons). My daughter loves Doctor Who and wanted to
dress up to go. I painstakingly made a
Dalek costume (one of the series' bad guys) by hand and we went on our way.
At the door she because nervous and didn’t want to go in. She didn’t
want people to laugh at her costume. I
told her no one would laugh at her. Within
moments of entering people pointed at her and said, “WOW! It’s a Dalek!” Every person who was dressed as the Doctor
asked if they could take a picture of her.
She posed for twenty pictures.
With each picture she smiled a bit more. With each picture she got more
into character. I told her that these
people were just like her. 5,000 people just like her. I think for the first
time she felt comfortable and when people said, “Don’t blink,” or “Exterminate!”
she knew exactly what they were talking about. She found other people who
understood what time paradoxes were; no one in her school did. She was one of them. And that’s all gifted kids want to be: part of
a group that can keep up mentally and think the way they do.
New York City Park Chess |
Help your child find his
niche. If he loves to read find or start
a reading group. If she likes science
find science clubs or summer science camp programs. If he likes art and music, take him to
concerts and stay around after and let him talk to the musicians, ask them
questions about what they do, and find a musician who wants to talk about his
favorite composer. If your child likes apples, go visit orchards or attend a
gardening club. Find that passion and
go! Go at all costs and go until they
tell you to stop, but only stop to go in another direction. Let them find themselves and find others like
them. Help them feel comfortable in
their skin. Let them break free of the
mold society puts them in. Society says “you
are nice little smart children and you will do well in school and do math and
read good books and behave and be the class president.” No!
You are going to dress up as Nikola Tesla for Halloween even if no one knows
who you are. You are going to compose
your own Ode to My Dog. You are going to
argue that a static warp bubble is the only way to travel faster than light and
using your imagination, your intellect, and your higher cognitive function you
will eventually design a warp engine. You
will paint the next masterpiece. You will write the great American novel
because you got the story idea when you were 10 and wrote it down to be
finished later when you learned the words you needed to get all your thoughts down. You can and will be everything and anything you choose and your
mind will set you free.
What Should Mom and Dad Do?
Parents need to enrich
their gifted children. Period. Even if your child is in a gifted education program, your involvement in key. It is
important to find activities that will enhance their learning and pique their
interests. Schools do their best, but they cannot expose every child to every aspect of life. Art museums are a great
start. Even if you don’t know anything
about art considers taking a guided tour.
Many museums have a free admission day.
Go. Libraries are also
important. Chances are your little
learner likes to read. Get that child a
library card and make the librarian your child’s best friend. A librarian can tease out specific interests
from a simple statement like, “I dunno. I kinda like science.” Next thing you know your child has an armful
of youth microbiology books. Every
newspaper has a section for local events.
Find them and go. Film shows, free music performances, lectures at
colleges, plays, etc. There is no excuse
to not enrich a child’s life outside of school. All educational programs have deficits. Find them and fill them yourself.
Parents need as much
support as kids. It’s tough to raise a
smart kid. They are always giving you a run for your money, soaking up every
experience they can, easily bored, and just all around great kids with
quirks. There is no better place to get
answers and supports than a support group. There are very few face to face
support groups but there are many on the internet. I belong to a gifted parenting group on
Facebook. Every member there has their
own stories, ask for help, and brag (yes. BRAG…something that parents of gifted
kids are often hesitant to do BUT WE WANT TO DO SOOOOO BAD!!!). There is a wealth of information out there from other parents. Learn from their mistakes. Learn from their successes. Don't be ashamed to post your mistakes either. We're all here because we love our kids and we want to give them the best opportunity to be themselves: smart.
Can't find a support group? Consider starting one on your own. It's not easy, but it is worth the time. Here are a few pointers: Starting a parent support group
Can't find a support group? Consider starting one on your own. It's not easy, but it is worth the time. Here are a few pointers: Starting a parent support group
We currently live in a culture of “dumb,” as I like to call it. There seems to be little value placed on
incredibly smart children and that is a great disservice to society. By embracing mediocrity and failure, we set
up our children to expect to fail resulting in a child’s apathy towards
education and success. This leads to
poor academic performance that excludes children from college or technical
schools which in turn increases crime, gangs, and prison for many
children. Don’t dumb things down.
Please consult the following links for more information:
The National Association for Gifted Children
Glossary of relative terms for Gifted Education
*I live in The Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. The accommodation of gifted education is state mandated.
Please consult the following links for more information:
The National Association for Gifted Children
Glossary of relative terms for Gifted Education
Part Two of this post will involve interviews with gifted children (their image of themselves, their gripes, and what they like), interviews with parents of gifted children (major difficulties and major joys), and gifted adults (reflections).
*I live in The Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. The accommodation of gifted education is state mandated.
No comments:
Post a Comment